Jump to content


Photo

Verizon Galaxy S4 or LG G2

Started by Cyber Warrior ,

  • Sign In To Reply:  

Cyber Warrior #1

Cyber Warrior
  • Robots Will Kill
  • Offline
  • 1500 posts
  • Location: New York
  • Device: GS4 N7

Posted Sep 28 '13 @ 12:11 PM

So after deciding it was time to sell my Galaxy S3 and upgrade to something newer, I had a really tough time deciding on a new phone... so I thought I'd share my experiences this past week.

 

Normally I've always been an impulse buyer, buying devices the first day they come out before even seeing them or playing with them. This time around I thought I'd make an educated purchase being that I was buying the device off contract at full retail and wanted to make sure I didn't have any regrets. I narrowed my choices down between the HTC One, Galaxy S4 and LG G2.

 

Coming from the GS3, I felt like I wanted something different, even though I love the GS3 I wanted my upgrade to feel like I was upgrading to something newer and not just the same device with a few extra features. So, the GS4 was kind of last on my list of choices. I didn't really spend too much time playing with the device because I had an idea of what it was all about already owning the previous version. I was getting a slightly larger screen with thinner bezels, better hardware and more TouchWiz features.

 

Spending some time with the LG G2 in store, my first impressions was the phone was amazing. The edge to edge screen with the minimal bezels looked amazing. The UI wasn't as bad as I thought it would be after seeing it in person. There's a lot of cool features as well as settings that I really enjoyed. My main concerns were the buttons on the back... I thought they would be way more pronounced and easier to feel.. even though I only spent about an hour with the phone, I had a hard time finding the power button, I was constantly pressing the volume up button... maybe over time I would have gotten better at it but I didn't like the idea of it being a guessing game every time I wanted to use the volume or power. On the other hand, the button location wasn't all that bad, it was very comfortable being that thats where my finger tends to rest when holding the phone, exactly as LG stated. Also there's a knock knock feature which turns the screen on and off by tapping the screen twice, so thats another option which I'm sure will come in handy. One of my main gripes was that there were hairline scratches all over the display unit, it quickly reminded me of the days of owning the Thunderbolt and how quickly the screen would scratch, even though its supposedly Gorilla glass. I owned two Thunderbolts, one being a replacement of the first, and on both devices within the first three days I had scratches. Never in the history of any other Android device have I ever had a scratch except for this one phone.. so seeing scratches on the LG G2, the only phone in the store with scratches, quickly scared me away. Overall I really liked the phone though, the Snapdragon S800 is the smoothest of any device that I've seen.. and thats with LG's heavily skinned UI.. the thing still flies.. swiping, scrolling and animations were butter smooth.. pure perfection.

 

My final decision of buying the Galaxy S4 came down to a few factors.. First was accessories.. because the LG G2 was one solid piece of plastic, I knew I needed a case. I probably wouldn't have used a case if the phone had a removable back piece, this way I could at least lay the phone down on surfaces and worst case scenario if the back gets scratched, I can replace it... well cant do that with a one piece design so I would definitely need a case. Now because the phone has an edge to edge screen with barely any side bezels what so ever.. I'm not even sure how a case would work on this phone without the lip partially covering the screen. Both the Galaxy S4 and LG G2 have glossy plastic.. huge fingerprint magnets, I knew I would want a nice case. The G2 is less popular so there aren't many cases to choose from and I couldn't find anything I liked. On the other hand the Galaxy S4 has a shit load of cases and accessories to choose from.. so the Galaxy S4 won that category for me. I ended up getting the Spigen Neo Hybrid which is a really nice case and highly recommend.

 

Next was re-sale value.. I like to constantly switch devices so knowing that I can get the most money out of a device when it comes time to sell it is very important for me. The Galaxy S4 being the more popular phone gave me comfort knowing I could easily sell it. Heck, I sold my Galaxy S3 for $300 used and its over a year old.

 

So I'm now the owner of a Galaxy S4, its nice having an all black phone again... my GS3 was white and those white bezels really are a distraction from the screen. After playing with the device for a few days I was quite surprised of how much I'm enjoying the phone. I was worried that it would feel the same as my GS3 but Samsung did a nice job of making just enough changes to where it feels like an upgrade over the GS3. Better hardware, newer software, some changes to the UI, the home button is easier to press and the overall design is very nice looking.

 

So thats my experience this past week, a very stressful decision.. I think from now on I'll just stick to my original plan of impulse buying devices on the first day.. putting too much thought into these things and you'll go crazy :D. Oh and I was able to get the phone at an upgrade discount (keeping my unlimited data) using my family plan and some swapping of devices which I'll write up separately how to do for those interested.

 

 


tacsig513.png

: : C  H  A  N  N  E  L   Y  O  U  R    M  E  D  I  A : :


Christopher Coleman #2

Christopher Coleman
  • Management
  • Offline
  • 877 posts
  • Location: Carbondale, IL
  • Device: Motorola RAZR MAXX & Nexus 7

Posted Sep 28 '13 @ 1:28 PM

The buttons on Verizon's version of the G2 are quite different from the original version. The scratches on the screen are disappointing but I'd have a screen protector put on in store to handle that.

Did the phone feel cheap to you or do you just feel the need to use a case with any plastic-backed phone?

Also, why was the Note 3 not in your original lineup?

Sent from my XT908 using Tapatalk 4



Cyber Warrior #3

Cyber Warrior
  • Robots Will Kill
  • Offline
  • 1500 posts
  • Location: New York
  • Device: GS4 N7

Posted Sep 28 '13 @ 1:48 PM

I heard the buttons on the Verizon version where actually better so I'd hate to see what the other carriers feel like. I really liked the phone but my main decision came down to I knew I would be casing the two phones, so I went with the more popular phone that had more accessories to offer... otherwise the LG G2 was a beautiful phone. I mainly use cases just so I can lay a phone down on a desk or something without it getting scratched or dirty.. I'm not looking for protection in case i drop the thing. If I weren't to use a case.. I would lay the phone down on its back. Now on devices with removable covers, if it gets scratched.. I can easily order a new one and snap it on. With devices that are one piece.. if it gets scratched, I'm f**ked. It's very important to me that my devices remain in mint condition so I can re-sell them when the time comes.

 

Also both phones are "cheap" glossy plastic, so a case to cover the back of the phone is a must for me. If the LG G2 were made out of the materials of say the HTC One or the new Droid Maxx (two phones that look like they wont scratch easy and don't attract fingerprints) ....then I would gladly keep the G2 naked and take my chances.

 

As cool as the Note lineup is.. The Note 3 is just way too big for me... plus recently selling my Nexus 10 and buying a Nexus 7.. the Nexus 7 is almost the same size  :P except I don't have all the cool features. If I were a white collared worker who carried a briefcase or some kind of man bag, I would gladly buy the Note... other than that its too big for my pockets.


tacsig513.png

: : C  H  A  N  N  E  L   Y  O  U  R    M  E  D  I  A : :


C Sab #4

C Sab
  • Your alternative tech/photography guy from the North.
  • Offline
  • 990 posts
  • Location: Canada
  • Device: Nexus 5, Nexus 10, Nikon D3100

Posted Sep 28 '13 @ 2:38 PM

Overall, I came to the same conclusion as you. After all the other phones, I still wanna get the S4 more than any other. It's the best phone to me.

 

Just out of curiosity, what factors led you to not choose the One? I know you mentioned it in your line-up but you didn't mention it after that.



Cyber Warrior #5

Cyber Warrior
  • Robots Will Kill
  • Offline
  • 1500 posts
  • Location: New York
  • Device: GS4 N7

Posted Sep 28 '13 @ 2:47 PM

Overall, I came to the same conclusion as you. After all the other phones, I still wanna get the S4 more than any other. It's the best phone to me.
 
Just out of curiosity, what factors led you to not choose the One? I know you mentioned it in your line-up but you didn't mention it after that.


I think the only thing I liked was the physical looks of the One. The screen was a little narrow, I prefer the wider screens. I'm not really a Sense fan anymore. Also the Dev community looks much better for the Galaxy phones.

My other decision was I was looking for something with the best re-sale value. I feel like the Verizon One was late to the game and nobody wants it. I MAY sell the GS4 if I hear the Nexus 5 comes to Verizon. So I want something I can quickly flip. However I'm really liking this phone.. but man I can imagine how KitKat will run on that S800,its a beast :)
  • Photopaul65 likes this

tacsig513.png

: : C  H  A  N  N  E  L   Y  O  U  R    M  E  D  I  A : :


Jerrod #6

Jerrod
  • Member
  • Offline
  • 265 posts
  • Location: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
  • Device: Nexus 5, Nexus 7 2012 tablet

Posted Sep 28 '13 @ 5:04 PM

Isn't the G2 is supposed to have Gorilla glass three?  If so I wonder if the scratches came from some rough mishandling,,,then again Gorilla glass is supposed to with stand this no? 



Cyber Warrior #7

Cyber Warrior
  • Robots Will Kill
  • Offline
  • 1500 posts
  • Location: New York
  • Device: GS4 N7

Posted Sep 28 '13 @ 5:12 PM

Isn't the G2 is supposed to have Gorilla glass three?  If so I wonder if the scratches came from some rough mishandling,,,then again Gorilla glass is supposed to with stand this no? 


I would assume so. What's funny is I was telling Cory about it and he said the Verizon store he went to had a scratched up G2 also. Out of all the stores I've been to I've never seen a display device have scratches so it was very strange. Now I understand these are display units (working) but I would have to think that the screen is the same quality as the inventory of devices that they sell. It's possible someone roughed it up pretty badly and under normal circumstances the screen would be more scratch resistant but it just gave me bad memories of my two Thunderbolts that were supposedly Gorilla glass but easily scratched.

tacsig513.png

: : C  H  A  N  N  E  L   Y  O  U  R    M  E  D  I  A : :


Christopher Coleman #8

Christopher Coleman
  • Management
  • Offline
  • 877 posts
  • Location: Carbondale, IL
  • Device: Motorola RAZR MAXX & Nexus 7

Posted Sep 28 '13 @ 5:45 PM

As far as I'm aware, Gorilla Glass is only scratch resistant against certain materials. I'm guessing some douchebag roughed it up with a diamond ring or something to that effect. Or, an employee used it previously and let it roll around next to a set of keys in their pocket.

Sent from my XT908 using Tapatalk 4



C Sab #9

C Sab
  • Your alternative tech/photography guy from the North.
  • Offline
  • 990 posts
  • Location: Canada
  • Device: Nexus 5, Nexus 10, Nikon D3100

Posted Sep 29 '13 @ 7:09 AM


Overall, I came to the same conclusion as you. After all the other phones, I still wanna get the S4 more than any other. It's the best phone to me.

Just out of curiosity, what factors led you to not choose the One? I know you mentioned it in your line-up but you didn't mention it after that.

I think the only thing I liked was the physical looks of the One. The screen was a little narrow, I prefer the wider screens. I'm not really a Sense fan anymore. Also the Dev community looks much better for the Galaxy phones.

My other decision was I was looking for something with the best re-sale value. I feel like the Verizon One was late to the game and nobody wants it. I MAY sell the GS4 if I hear the Nexus 5 comes to Verizon. So I want something I can quickly flip. However I'm really liking this phone.. but man I can imagine how KitKat will run on that S800,its a beast :)

After using an HTC for almost 2 years, I can say that the only thing I really like about Sense 5 is the color scheme. Also, I'm a dude who needs his microSD slot lol

Sent from my GT-S7560M using Tapatalk 4

Updated by C Sab, Sep 29 '13 @ 7:12 AM.


Johnny5 #10

Johnny5
  • Member
  • Offline
  • 89 posts

Posted Sep 29 '13 @ 4:32 PM

So after deciding it was time to sell my Galaxy S3 and upgrade to something newer, I had a really tough time deciding on a new phone... so I thought I'd share my experiences this past week.

Normally I've always been an impulse buyer, buying devices the first day they come out before even seeing them or playing with them. This time around I thought I'd make an educated purchase being that I was buying the device off contract at full retail and wanted to make sure I didn't have any regrets. I narrowed my choices down between the HTC One, Galaxy S4 and LG G2.

Coming from the GS3, I felt like I wanted something different, even though I love the GS3 I wanted my upgrade to feel like I was upgrading to something newer and not just the same device with a few extra features. So, the GS4 was kind of last on my list of choices. I didn't really spend too much time playing with the device because I had an idea of what it was all about already owning the previous version. I was getting a slightly larger screen with thinner bezels, better hardware and more TouchWiz features.

Spending some time with the LG G2 in store, my first impressions was the phone was amazing. The edge to edge screen with the minimal bezels looked amazing. The UI wasn't as bad as I thought it would be after seeing it in person. There's a lot of cool features as well as settings that I really enjoyed. My main concerns were the buttons on the back... I thought they would be way more pronounced and easier to feel.. even though I only spent about an hour with the phone, I had a hard time finding the power button, I was constantly pressing the volume up button... maybe over time I would have gotten better at it but I didn't like the idea of it being a guessing game every time I wanted to use the volume or power. On the other hand, the button location wasn't all that bad, it was very comfortable being that thats where my finger tends to rest when holding the phone, exactly as LG stated. Also there's a knock knock feature which turns the screen on and off by tapping the screen twice, so thats another option which I'm sure will come in handy. One of my main gripes was that there were hairline scratches all over the display unit, it quickly reminded me of the days of owning the Thunderbolt and how quickly the screen would scratch, even though its supposedly Gorilla glass. I owned two Thunderbolts, one being a replacement of the first, and on both devices within the first three days I had scratches. Never in the history of any other Android device have I ever had a scratch except for this one phone.. so seeing scratches on the LG G2, the only phone in the store with scratches, quickly scared me away. Overall I really liked the phone though, the Snapdragon S800 is the smoothest of any device that I've seen.. and thats with LG's heavily skinned UI.. the thing still flies.. swiping, scrolling and animations were butter smooth.. pure perfection.

My final decision of buying the Galaxy S4 came down to a few factors.. First was accessories.. because the LG G2 was one solid piece of plastic, I knew I needed a case. I probably wouldn't have used a case if the phone had a removable back piece, this way I could at least lay the phone down on surfaces and worst case scenario if the back gets scratched, I can replace it... well cant do that with a one piece design so I would definitely need a case. Now because the phone has an edge to edge screen with barely any side bezels what so ever.. I'm not even sure how a case would work on this phone without the lip partially covering the screen. Both the Galaxy S4 and LG G2 have glossy plastic.. huge fingerprint magnets, I knew I would want a nice case. The G2 is less popular so there aren't many cases to choose from and I couldn't find anything I liked. On the other hand the Galaxy S4 has a shit load of cases and accessories to choose from.. so the Galaxy S4 won that category for me. I ended up getting the Spigen Neo Hybrid which is a really nice case and highly recommend.

Next was re-sale value.. I like to constantly switch devices so knowing that I can get the most money out of a device when it comes time to sell it is very important for me. The Galaxy S4 being the more popular phone gave me comfort knowing I could easily sell it. Heck, I sold my Galaxy S3 for $300 used and its over a year old.

So I'm now the owner of a Galaxy S4, its nice having an all black phone again... my GS3 was white and those white bezels really are a distraction from the screen. After playing with the device for a few days I was quite surprised of how much I'm enjoying the phone. I was worried that it would feel the same as my GS3 but Samsung did a nice job of making just enough changes to where it feels like an upgrade over the GS3. Better hardware, newer software, some changes to the UI, the home button is easier to press and the overall design is very nice looking.

So thats my experience this past week, a very stressful decision.. I think from now on I'll just stick to my original plan of impulse buying devices on the first day.. putting too much thought into these things and you'll go crazy :D. Oh and I was able to get the phone at an upgrade discount (keeping my unlimited data) using my family plan and some swapping of devices which I'll write up separately how to do for those interested.

The lg g2 is a total flop. Glad you came to your senses.

Sent from my SCH-I605 using Tapatalk 2



C Sab #11

C Sab
  • Your alternative tech/photography guy from the North.
  • Offline
  • 990 posts
  • Location: Canada
  • Device: Nexus 5, Nexus 10, Nikon D3100

Posted Sep 30 '13 @ 5:53 AM

So after deciding it was time to sell my Galaxy S3 and upgrade to something newer, I had a really tough time deciding on a new phone... so I thought I'd share my experiences this past week.

Normally I've always been an impulse buyer, buying devices the first day they come out before even seeing them or playing with them. This time around I thought I'd make an educated purchase being that I was buying the device off contract at full retail and wanted to make sure I didn't have any regrets. I narrowed my choices down between the HTC One, Galaxy S4 and LG G2.

Coming from the GS3, I felt like I wanted something different, even though I love the GS3 I wanted my upgrade to feel like I was upgrading to something newer and not just the same device with a few extra features. So, the GS4 was kind of last on my list of choices. I didn't really spend too much time playing with the device because I had an idea of what it was all about already owning the previous version. I was getting a slightly larger screen with thinner bezels, better hardware and more TouchWiz features.

Spending some time with the LG G2 in store, my first impressions was the phone was amazing. The edge to edge screen with the minimal bezels looked amazing. The UI wasn't as bad as I thought it would be after seeing it in person. There's a lot of cool features as well as settings that I really enjoyed. My main concerns were the buttons on the back... I thought they would be way more pronounced and easier to feel.. even though I only spent about an hour with the phone, I had a hard time finding the power button, I was constantly pressing the volume up button... maybe over time I would have gotten better at it but I didn't like the idea of it being a guessing game every time I wanted to use the volume or power. On the other hand, the button location wasn't all that bad, it was very comfortable being that thats where my finger tends to rest when holding the phone, exactly as LG stated. Also there's a knock knock feature which turns the screen on and off by tapping the screen twice, so thats another option which I'm sure will come in handy. One of my main gripes was that there were hairline scratches all over the display unit, it quickly reminded me of the days of owning the Thunderbolt and how quickly the screen would scratch, even though its supposedly Gorilla glass. I owned two Thunderbolts, one being a replacement of the first, and on both devices within the first three days I had scratches. Never in the history of any other Android device have I ever had a scratch except for this one phone.. so seeing scratches on the LG G2, the only phone in the store with scratches, quickly scared me away. Overall I really liked the phone though, the Snapdragon S800 is the smoothest of any device that I've seen.. and thats with LG's heavily skinned UI.. the thing still flies.. swiping, scrolling and animations were butter smooth.. pure perfection.

My final decision of buying the Galaxy S4 came down to a few factors.. First was accessories.. because the LG G2 was one solid piece of plastic, I knew I needed a case. I probably wouldn't have used a case if the phone had a removable back piece, this way I could at least lay the phone down on surfaces and worst case scenario if the back gets scratched, I can replace it... well cant do that with a one piece design so I would definitely need a case. Now because the phone has an edge to edge screen with barely any side bezels what so ever.. I'm not even sure how a case would work on this phone without the lip partially covering the screen. Both the Galaxy S4 and LG G2 have glossy plastic.. huge fingerprint magnets, I knew I would want a nice case. The G2 is less popular so there aren't many cases to choose from and I couldn't find anything I liked. On the other hand the Galaxy S4 has a shit load of cases and accessories to choose from.. so the Galaxy S4 won that category for me. I ended up getting the Spigen Neo Hybrid which is a really nice case and highly recommend.

Next was re-sale value.. I like to constantly switch devices so knowing that I can get the most money out of a device when it comes time to sell it is very important for me. The Galaxy S4 being the more popular phone gave me comfort knowing I could easily sell it. Heck, I sold my Galaxy S3 for $300 used and its over a year old.

So I'm now the owner of a Galaxy S4, its nice having an all black phone again... my GS3 was white and those white bezels really are a distraction from the screen. After playing with the device for a few days I was quite surprised of how much I'm enjoying the phone. I was worried that it would feel the same as my GS3 but Samsung did a nice job of making just enough changes to where it feels like an upgrade over the GS3. Better hardware, newer software, some changes to the UI, the home button is easier to press and the overall design is very nice looking.

So thats my experience this past week, a very stressful decision.. I think from now on I'll just stick to my original plan of impulse buying devices on the first day.. putting too much thought into these things and you'll go crazy :D. Oh and I was able to get the phone at an upgrade discount (keeping my unlimited data) using my family plan and some swapping of devices which I'll write up separately how to do for those interested.

The lg g2 is a total flop. Glad you came to your senses.

Sent from my SCH-I605 using Tapatalk 2

How is it a flop?

Sent from my GT-S7560M using Tapatalk 4



Johnny5 #12

Johnny5
  • Member
  • Offline
  • 89 posts

Posted Oct 6 '13 @ 8:01 PM

Sorry.....it is okay. Just in a mood to hate on stuff ha ha.

Sent from my XT1060 using Tapatalk now Free



C Sab #13

C Sab
  • Your alternative tech/photography guy from the North.
  • Offline
  • 990 posts
  • Location: Canada
  • Device: Nexus 5, Nexus 10, Nikon D3100

Posted Oct 7 '13 @ 2:51 PM

haha I see. :P